This is how much your degree will earn you in 10 years
Around a quarter of degrees in the UK will not give students high enough post-education earnings to justify their cost, according to new research.
A report has found that too many prospective students are being sold a 'false dream' when it comes to the degrees they enrol onto.
The report, produced by centre-right think tank Onward, said 40% of undergraduates are doing degrees which, after five years, lead to median earnings which fall below what was the loan repayment threshold at the time (£25,000 – it's now £27,725).
Now ministers are being urged to cull places on these courses and increase the number of spots available on technical courses (which often have better employment rates and earnings potential).
The study comes at a time when Philip Augar’s review of post-18 education funding is looking into a range of issues, including how much tuition fees should be and how much funding students should receive.
The long term earning potential of degrees
|Subjects||One year after grad||Three years after grad||Five years after grad||Ten years after grad|
|Medicine & Dentistry||£36,000||£42,800||£47,300||£55,100|
|Engineering & Technology||£25,100||£29,500||£32,600||£40,000|
|Architecture, Building & Planning||£23,200||£28,600||£30,900||£36,600|
|Business & Administrative Studies||£19,400||£23,400||£26,800||£32,200|
|Languages (excluding English Studies)||£19,300||£24,100||£27,400||£31,000|
|Biological Sciences (excluding Psychology)||£16,200||£21,100||£24,500||£30,700|
|Subjects Allied to Medicine (excluding Nursing)||£21,000||£24,400||£26,400||£29,600|
|Historical & Philosophical Studies||£17,400||£22,200||£25,400||£29,300|
|Social Studies (excluding Economics)||£18,000||£21,800||£24,500||£28,900|
|Mass Communications & Documentation||£15,900||£19,700||£22,800||£27,300|
|Agriculture & Related Subjects||£16,500||£19,100||£20,500||£24,300|
|Creative Arts & Design||£14,300||£17,800||£20,200||£23,200|
Students often take on the debt of university because they believe it will be worth it in the long run, and lead to them getting a better job.
Recently, however, MPs have said university graduates aren’t getting a good enough return on their degrees. Despite the £9,250 per year tuition fees on most courses, over 80% of graduates will never earn enough to pay the full loan back.
And with the average debt after an undergraduate degree now £50,000, some degrees are looking pretty expensive considering the earning potential.
The table above, taken from Onward's report and formed using LEO Graduate outcomes data, shows that the arts and more creative subjects lead to lower financial reward no matter what the timescale.
Contrastingly, STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics) lead to higher earnings, both in the short and long term.
The report also revealed that 10% of students are studying for degrees that, even after 10 years, will lead to median earnings of less than £25,000 – what was the threshold for repaying your student loan when the study was published.
In other words, 134,000 graduates every year won’t start paying their loan back even ten years after accepting their degree certificate.
What else did the report find?
The think tank’s report acknowledges that “education has a value in its own right” and “earning a living is not the only reason people study”.
However, it says this doesn't remove the problem that too many people “are being sold on a false promise”.
Before you get a degree it can be really easy to assume you'll find your dream job upon graduation, but this simply isn’t true in most cases.
Indeed, the report found that in the 2015/16 academic year, between 18 – 25% of undergraduates were doing degrees that would fail to deliver a lifetime earnings premium (how much extra you'll earn with a degree compared to someone without one) or justify the average student debt.
What’s more, 20% of students are no better off five years graduation than if they had decided to opt for an alternative to university, like an apprenticeship.
How should the government respond?
The report suggests that repayments on Student Loans are halved through the introduction of tax cuts for graduates, worth 50p in every pound owed.
It also argues that courses offering the lowest earning potential ten years after graduation should have their number of places lowered.
Onward also suggest that the number of people in post-18 technical education needs to increase, as they believe it is unfairly seen as the “ugly duckling” of British education.
Tory MP, Neil O’Brien, said to the BBC:
Too many students are being effectively missold a university education.
[There is] a substantial minority who don’t earn much but get left with big debts. We should steer people away from courses that don’t lead to good outcomes.
The suggestions are fairly radical. What about the people who want to study the degrees that 'don’t earn enough' because they have an interest in the subject? Is it really appropriate to assess the value of a university education solely on earning potential?
The report into post-18 educational funding is due to report back as soon as next month, so whatever happens, we'll let you know!
Want a more detailed breakdown of graduate salaries? We've got the graduate earnings for 70 subjects right here!